Use the form below or call us at (856) 212-1330
Replacing a fence means taking the whole run out and starting over — new posts, new footings, new panels. Liberi Fence is a third-generation, family-owned fence company in Turnersville, and we replace residential and commercial fences across all seven South Jersey counties: Gloucester, Camden, Burlington, Salem, Cumberland, Atlantic, and Cape May. Most of the fences we take down failed at the posts, not the panels — which is the single thing that decides whether you are looking at a repair or a replacement.
Replace the fence when the posts have failed; repair it when only the panels or hardware have. That is the whole test, and it is why a fence that looks bad in three places can often be repaired while a fence that looks fine but wobbles usually cannot. A post that moves when you push on it has lost its footing, and a new panel bolted to a failing post fails again within a season.
Here is how we assess a fence when we come out to look at it.
| What we find | What it means | Typical outcome |
|---|---|---|
| One or two panels damaged, posts firm and plumb | Impact damage — a vehicle, a falling limb, a fallen tree | Section repair |
| Posts soft at ground line, panels still intact | Rot at the soil interface, the most common wood failure in South Jersey | Full replacement |
| Fence leaning as a run, no single point of damage | Footings undersized or set above frost depth | Full replacement |
| Multiple sections down after a wind event | Wind load exceeded post capacity along the line | Full replacement, often insurance-funded |
| Gate sags, drags, or will not latch; fence otherwise sound | Gate post is undersized or has shifted | Gate post reset or rebuild |
| Fence is at or past its service life for the material | Repairs will keep recurring in new spots | Replacement is the cheaper path |
If you are weighing this against how long the fence should have lasted in the first place, our guide to the lifespan of a South Jersey fence covers what to expect from each material in this climate.
Nor'easters and summer thunderstorm downbursts are what take down most South Jersey fences, and solid privacy panels take the worst of it because they act as a sail. A six-foot solid privacy fence presents roughly twice the wind surface of a shadowbox or spaced-picket fence of the same height, which is why two neighbors with different fence styles often get very different outcomes from the same storm.
What matters after a storm is that wind damage is rarely isolated. When a gust lays down three sections, the posts on either side of them have usually been racked and loosened even though they are still standing. Replacing only the visibly downed sections leaves the weakened posts in the ground, and the next storm finds them. We walk the entire run and test every post before quoting, so what you get priced is the actual condition of the fence rather than the part of it that is lying on the lawn.
Before you clear anything: photograph the damage from several angles, including wide shots that show the whole fence line, and leave the debris in place until you have those pictures. Insurers are looking at extent, and extent is very hard to prove once the yard is tidy. The National Weather Service office in Mount Holly publishes storm reports for our area, which is useful documentation for the date of the event.
In most standard homeowners policies, a fence is covered under "other structures" — the same category as a detached garage or shed — usually at a percentage of the dwelling coverage limit. Whether a specific claim pays depends on the cause of loss, your deductible, and whether the policy settles at replacement cost or actual cash value.
The practical consequence is worth knowing before you call your carrier: because insurers pay to restore the fence to its pre-loss condition, a covered wind claim generally funds replacing the affected run rather than patching individual panels. Read your own declarations page for the "other structures" limit and your deductible, and ask your agent whether the policy is replacement cost or actual cash value — those two answers determine most of the outcome.
This is general information about how fence claims usually work, not insurance advice — your policy language governs, and your agent or carrier is the authority on your specific coverage.
A replacement is a demolition job followed by an installation job, and most of what goes wrong on other people's fences happens in the part nobody photographs — the holes.
We walk the property line with you, measure the run, test every existing post, and identify obstacles: old concrete footings, tree roots, grade changes, and where the gates need to go. Estimates are free and itemized, so you can see removal, materials, and labor as separate lines.
Every job goes through New Jersey One Call before digging. Under the state's Underground Facility Protection Act, the request must be made at least three full business days before work starts, excluding weekends and holidays, and installing or replacing a fence is named explicitly in the law's list of covered work. Digging must then begin within ten business days, and the ticket stays valid for forty-five. This is the single biggest reason no legitimate fence contractor can start the morning after you sign — and if one offers to, they are skipping the markout.
Fence permit requirements, height limits, and survey requirements are set by your municipality, not by the state, and they vary meaningfully across South Jersey — a corner lot in Cherry Hill, a historic district property in Haddonfield, and a farm parcel in Salem County are three different sets of rules. We tell you what your township requires before the job starts. If you have a pool, the barrier has to meet New Jersey's pool code under the Uniform Construction Code, including self-closing and self-latching gate hardware.
The old fence comes out, including the footings. Pulling the old concrete rather than digging beside it is what stops the new posts from being set in disturbed or obstructed ground, and it is why we haul debris off site rather than stacking it at the curb.
Post holes are dug below the local frost line so seasonal freeze-thaw cannot heave them, and post depth and diameter are set by the fence type, the height, and how exposed the run is to wind. Soil matters here: sandy Pinelands ground in Medford or Hammonton behaves differently from the heavier clay closer to the Delaware, and gate posts and corner posts carry loads that line posts do not.
A replacement is the one moment when switching materials costs you nothing extra in labor, because the old fence is coming out and new posts are going in either way. That makes it the right time to reconsider the material rather than defaulting to what was there.
| Material | Best case for replacing with it | What to weigh |
|---|---|---|
| Vinyl / PVC | Homeowners tired of staining and repairing wood; full privacy | Higher material cost; solid panels carry the most wind load |
| Wood — cedar or pressure-treated | Matching a neighborhood look; historic districts; largest runs | Needs sealing; posts are the component that eventually fails |
| Aluminum / ornamental | Pool enclosures, sloped yards, and shore properties | Not a privacy fence; powder coat resists salt air far better than steel |
| Chain link | Dog runs, commercial sites, and the largest perimeters per dollar | No privacy unless slats are added |
We carry Illusions Vinyl Fence, including the Grand Illusions Color Spectrum and WoodBond lines, and if you are torn between the two most common choices our breakdown of vinyl versus wood for a South Jersey home goes deeper. For what the project itself is likely to run, see how much fencing costs in NJ.
Repair is cheaper in the moment and replacement is usually cheaper over time. The deciding factor is the posts: repairing panels attached to failing posts means paying twice, because the repair fails with the post. If more than a third of the posts are soft, loose, or heaving, replacement is generally the lower total cost.
It depends on linear footage, material, height, the number of gates, and what has to come out first. Removal and haul-away of the old fence, grade changes, and obstructions like old footings or tree roots all affect the number. We measure on site and give you an itemized estimate at no charge — see our NJ fencing cost guide for what drives the figure.
It depends on the cause. Sudden losses such as wind, falling trees, vehicle impact, and vandalism are typically covered under "other structures." Gradual rot, insect damage, and ordinary wear generally are not, because insurers treat those as maintenance. Your deductible and whether the policy pays replacement cost or actual cash value determine what actually reaches you.
Responsibility follows ownership, and ownership follows the property line — which is why a survey matters when a fence sits on or near the boundary. If the fence is entirely on your side, it is yours to replace. If it straddles the line, it is generally a shared structure and both owners have an interest in it. Municipal rules and any recorded agreements govern the specifics, so confirm the line before work starts.
Usually yes, and it is set by your municipality rather than the state. Most South Jersey townships require a zoning permit for a fence, and many impose different height limits for front yards than for rear yards. Corner lots often have sight-triangle restrictions, and some towns require a survey. We confirm what your specific township requires before the job is scheduled.
The install itself is typically a short job for a residential run, but the schedule is set by the utility markout through New Jersey One Call and by your township's permit turnaround, both of which happen before anyone digs. Material availability also matters — in-stock materials generally move in a few business days, while special orders take longer. We give you the current timeline when we quote.
We work out of Turnersville in Washington Township, and what a replacement actually involves changes as you move across the region — the soil, the wind exposure, and the housing stock are all different at the shore than they are along the river or out in the farm country.
We measure the run, test every post, and give you an itemized estimate covering removal, materials, and labor — at no cost and with no obligation. Serving Gloucester, Camden, Burlington, Salem, Cumberland, Atlantic, and Cape May counties.
Liberi Fence, LLC
141 Ganttown Road, Suite B2, Turnersville, NJ 08012
(856) 212-1330 · phone lines open 24/7 · office visits by appointment
Family-owned and operated, third generation. Free delivery on materials up to 200 miles.
